Hi amidst_the_stars, I find that your posts are generally sensible and reasonable, well, at least most of the time. What puzzle me is, what gives u the impression that u have the right to criticise Joanne Peh while others do not have the right to criticise Joe Tay. Isnt this double standard that u have? U mean choosing a right role for herself is not within her control? Rejecting a role clearly unsuitable for herself, be it age wise or appearance wise is beyond her control? Learning to pronounce her own role name properly and acting naturally (but not overacting) are all not part of her job? Seriously her acting is quite average to me. Its quite a well known fact that her one and only Best Actress award was given to her, more as a consolation, after Fann, the newcomer then, won. You have asked a very good question. Why are viewers not criticising Xiang Yun, Chen Liping and Fann Wong (or at least, as much)? The reason is very simple. These actresses are at least delivering up to the expectation of the viewers and at the same time, not taking undeserving titles. Hope u will take this positively.